Caravanning v. motorhoming?

Apr 4, 2005
845
0
0
Visit site
Hi everyone

We have been caravanners for 30 years and we are now retired. I have a growing feeling that I fancy motorhoming, feeling that sometimes it might be easier etc. The problem is MOH does not have the same thoughts! So from anybody who has had both can you answer the question and what are the pros and cons?

Thanks Chris
 
Mar 14, 2005
1,476
1
0
Visit site
Chris, I turned to MH's 2 years ago after caravanning for 20 years and love it. For us it a a different form of camping as we tour a lot more and stay in one place for no more than 3 - 4 days.

There advantages amd disadvantages. The main disadvantage is that if you want to leave site for shopping, sight seeing etc you do not have the car [unless you tow one which is not for me]. You can overcome some of this by careful planning.

A MH is a large investment and I strongly suggest that you visit a MH show such as the one taking place at Shepton Mallet this weekend. There will be hundreds of owners rallying there who will be quite happy to talk to you and loads of MH's for sale. It is important to get the right layout for you and your partner.

I use a forum www.motorhomefacts.co.uk which is similar to this forum in having knowlegable and experienced members in their particular form of touring. I hope that the moderators on this forum do not mind me referencing it, I do the same for this forum when a question regarding towing crops up on the MH forum.
 
Mar 13, 2007
1,750
0
0
Visit site
hi Chris

we have had both and enjoyed the pleasure of both worlds we got our first van just after we were married with a very small ace 10footer as the kids came along the vans got bigger, when they had all left home the van seemed empty with just two of us and it did not get used very often so we bought a m/home instead and loved it finally it died as the base vehicle deteriated after 10years. as the cost of replacement was too high we went back to a tourer just a small 2 berth one like we started with all those years ago allthough now of course with all the mod cons.

right whats the pro's and cons you ask:- well I will try and explain.

good points

1 the m/home is more versitile and can be better at touring as you dont have to go back after a day out(if you book daily) just stay were ever you are.

2 you dont have to tow it any where and if you have a boat bike ect can be used as a tow car.

3 they are self contained and are ready to move within 5 mins and after stopping enroute climb out of the seat and your in your van.

4 you do see more as your routes can be planned to include places that would be impractical to take the tourer.

bad points

1 extra tax insurance ect the need for a 2nd car

2 sheer cost they are an expensive bit of kit

3 they are based on a van so are only as good as the vehicle itself

4 can be hard to park height restrictions size of parking bays ect

5 every thing has to be packed up before moving (allthough this takes only mins

6 often on a site you will return to find some moron has pinch your pitch despite leaving bucket reserved sign ect on the pitch

7they tend to have less storage space than the equivalent size van.

thats about it hope this helps if there is anything else I will post later got to go out now

colin
 
G

Guest

Colin has given a pretty accurate view point on the pros and cons. However as with everything there are always variations and just to stir the 'pot' a bit I offer the following observations.

A motorhome does not necessarily mean having a 2nd car. Many people buy motorhomes that are not much longer than large saloons and fit under the 6 meter price barrier for ferries. These still can provide good space and a washroom. In this case many people who have retired just use it as a daily vehicle as it can be parked in supermarkets without too much fuss. If you havea drive at your home, then no problem. Of course multi story carparks are out of the question. If you wish to leave the vehicle on a sitee, then many people use a scooter, fully automatic and electric start for getting around. saves on finding a parking space as well. Also if you live in a city as I do, then having a car is not that much of an advantage. We use the excellent bus service and again save parking fees, especially as being over 60 I have a free travel bus pass.

They are indeed expensive to buy new but if you were to add the total cost of a new caravan and car then the difference is not so great. Plus the 2nd hand market can throw up anything from a bargain to a 'dog'.

Although there is the possibility of some 'moron' taking your pitch, it does not happen that often to really worry about it, especially on CC/C&CC sites where you can mark your pitch with anice little sign. In Europe you often find tables and chairs 'sitting' on a pitch and you know why.

Motorhomes hold their value better than cars and caravans so if you buy one, you should see a reasonable return after even a fair number of years. Just look at the small ads to see the prices being asked for 10 year old models. Also as it is based on a commercial vehicle it is built stronger and should last longer. The main bug bear is people not using them enough and the engines fail due to lack of use.

The other advantage is the payload. In most motorhomes this is in the order of 500+ kg, show me any caravan that is looking at that. No problems in carrying all that 'junk' you like, and plenty of room for wine on the way back from France.

The main disadvanatage is lack of moving space. Many have to cram quite a lot into a smallish space and if you include a fixedbed, then the living space is restricted. Many often encourage you to use the cab seats, which some like, others not.

Insuring a motorhome is the same as any large car and the tax regime is the same as they are classified as 'private light goods' vehicles.

If you go to France you can use the network of Aires and pay as little as _3 per night.

With all these positives, why do i have a caravan? Well, we did have a motorhome but sold it many years back due to relocating abroad. When we came back we looked at a caravan as we already had a car and we live iin a flat wher we cannot park either a motorhome or caravan. However, the flame is still burning in my mind and we may revert if i can persuade SWMBO to let me part with the cash.

As mentioned above go to one of the big Shows and browse.
 
Apr 4, 2005
845
0
0
Visit site
Thank you all for such helpful advice. You have covered many of my questions and I still feel very enthusiastic. I think the next step for us is to hire one for a short break. I have said to my husband that we BOTH have to do so with a very open mind and then be totally honest at the end of the trial. Cost and running costs is a big issue for him which of course is important, but I feel that touring is more the type of holiday we would now enjoy, without, as you say, having to always return at the end of the day. I see many places I would like to look at, but not necessarily want to stay at for any length of time, hence the motorhome.

Thank you again for your opinions.

Chris
 
Mar 14, 2005
1,476
1
0
Visit site
Chris, I turned to MH's 2 years ago after caravanning for 20 years and love it. For us it a a different form of camping as we tour a lot more and stay in one place for no more than 3 - 4 days.

There advantages amd disadvantages. The main disadvantage is that if you want to leave site for shopping, sight seeing etc you do not have the car [unless you tow one which is not for me]. You can overcome some of this by careful planning.

A MH is a large investment and I strongly suggest that you visit a MH show such as the one taking place at Shepton Mallet this weekend. There will be hundreds of owners rallying there who will be quite happy to talk to you and loads of MH's for sale. It is important to get the right layout for you and your partner.

I use a forum www.motorhomefacts.co.uk which is similar to this forum in having knowlegable and experienced members in their particular form of touring. I hope that the moderators on this forum do not mind me referencing it, I do the same for this forum when a question regarding towing crops up on the MH forum.
Sorry, should have been www.motorhomefacts.com
 

Mel

Moderator
Mar 17, 2007
5,702
1,662
25,935
Visit site
Hi. we had a coachbuilt motorhome before we had a caravan. We had a number of happy holidays in it. I think that if your style of holidaying is to move from one site to another every few days, go for the motorhome. If you want to pitch and stay put for a week or two, then caravan. This is why we swapped- we were effectivly using the motorhome as a cramped caravan and it was a pain every time we wanted to go on an outing, shopping etc. Just remember that even if you tow a car to get over this problem you still need to move the van to empty the grey water, and fill the fresh water tank. Of course you can use a waste master and a water carrier, but now a MH is really starting to look like an expensive but small caravan. Hiring is a good idea to give it a try.

hope this helps

mel
 

Mel

Moderator
Mar 17, 2007
5,702
1,662
25,935
Visit site
P.S. No-one has mentioned that free standing motorhome awnings are a total and unmitigated pain. Reversing the motorhome onto the pitch to get the doors lined up and the awning close to the vehicle makes manouvering a caravan look easy. And then you have to throw the cords over the roof! small crowds gather to watch this. If you go for it, get a wind out awning or don't bother.

mel
 
Jan 19, 2008
9,103
0
0
Visit site
I like space and not to feel confined, I also like to stretch out. In the MH SL describes this you haven't got, you often have to use the seats that you've had your ass parked in for the X amount of miles driving to the site. To get the same amount of space I have in the Vermont I would need a large MH and this is out of the question for reasons already posted above. I have looked at MH and considered the advantages/disadvantages and a caravan won hands down. In a nutshell you have to make your own decision because what suits one doesn't always suit another. Good luck in whatever you choose.
 
Jun 28, 2007
515
0
0
Visit site
Hi Chris

I've motorhomed for 30+years before swapping to a caravan a couple of years ago. We're now seriously considering moving back to a MH.

The adavantages and disadvantages have been well covered and there are equal numbers of each for both a caravan and MH

One disadvantage I get puzzled with is the

'You have to pack everything up before moving on'

Well dont you have to do the very same in a caravan ? only this maybe just the once on ending your vacation but probably a lot more stuff.

However I hate clutter so everything has a place and is put in its place when not being used so to be honest there's little left 'out' to be packed away anyway.

MHs and caravans are personal things. I love motorhomes because you can get away very quickly without the need for hitching un hitching and all the stuff that goes with a caravan. For someone like me who doesn't get home from work till after 6pm I cant get away for the weekends I desire and therefore we only use the caravan for main holidays.

One of the main drawbacks that people mention is not having a car to get around. Again a bit of thought can solve this one.

Local buses or taxi's or walking / cycling can be just as good. with a bit of planning and research you can find plenty of sites where you dont actually need a car. For instance we've stayed at the Ayr holiday site in St Ives (Cornwall) which is a short (all be it steep) walk into the town and never needed a car. We also have visited St Ives in a 7.5m motorhome , parked on the leisure centre and caught the park and ride. So you can see with some input you can overcome the disadvantages.

Both caravans and motohomes are a compromise , its how you work with them that matters and as long as the your main needs are met in either then you should enjoy.
 
Apr 4, 2005
845
0
0
Visit site
Mel,LB and RogerP - thank you all for your thoughts and some very valid points. I think my main problem is that I don't feel confident in towing the caravan but feel better about driving a motorhome. Perhaps this is the problem I need to conquer.
 
G

Guest

Try taking one of the towing courses offered by the C and C&CC, it may help boost your confidence. Also try towing with an automatic vehicle. Not having to worry about gears means you can concentrate more on what is happening outside. My wife only has an automatic licence and as the kids tell her 'she drives the 'pedal car' very well. Hill starts are a doddle. She does baulk a bit at reversing, but on site we use a mover.

Basically, the more you do it, the more confident you will become.
 
G

Guest

Try taking one of the towing courses offered by the C and C&CC, it may help boost your confidence. Also try towing with an automatic vehicle. Not having to worry about gears means you can concentrate more on what is happening outside. My wife only has an automatic licence and as the kids tell her 'she drives the 'pedal car' very well. Hill starts are a doddle. She does baulk a bit at reversing, but on site we use a mover.

Basically, the more you do it, the more confident you will become.
'C' should read CC
 
Apr 4, 2005
845
0
0
Visit site
That is some of the problem Scotch Lad. We have just changed from an automatic to a manual and I agree, I do not feel as confident in that. I have thought about the course, and maybe that would help.
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts