Al-Ko Secure Wheel Lock - Is this the Achilles Heel?

Oct 25, 2006
97
0
0
Visit site
The van I am taking delivery of in May comes with a Receiver for the Al-Ko Secure Wheel Lock and in considering paying out the not inconsiderable sum of £235 for the actual lock the words 'puncture and security' crossed my mind.

It appears that, as the representative of Coachman stated, spare wheels have a steeel rim as is standard within the industry and the Al-Ko Secure will not fit to the spare wheel!

The representative goes on to say, that the purpose of the spare wheel is to enable the caravan to be towed but with a view to the original wheel being repaired at the earliest opportunity.

Whilst these sentiments might be supported of repairing the puncture quickly, it does appear that should a puncture occur in the nearside wheel, and the spare is fitted, the van is vulnerable to theft and the Al-Ko Secure rendered uselessfor the period it remains fitted. Unless of course one goes the the rather extraordinary lenghts of changing the un-punctured offside wheel to the near side!

Why cannot the steel rimmed spare be 'punched' to the same shape/design as the Alloy wheel to overcome this seemingly 'achilles heel'?

Should I seek to purchase a third alloy wheel, assuming that it will fit the spare wheel carrier, or am I panicking unnecessarily?

For cars adopting the same principle of the spare steel rim as opposed to the normal tyres running on alloys, it goes without saying that the same security problem faced with a caravan does not arise.

Is this the weak point of the Al-Ko Secure?

Any views would be appreciated.
 
Mar 4, 2007
85
0
0
Visit site
I can see your point, however, as it would be a temporary situation, how about a locking wheel stud as used on cars, to prevent the possibility of the van taking a walk?

Just a thought
 
Mar 14, 2005
4,638
0
0
Visit site
You are right about it being a weak point

I got 20% discount via C & CC ins for having the Alko wheel clamp but what would happen insurance wise in the unlikely event of the van being stolen when fitted with the steel spare ??

There would seem to be a few options

1 Take the van to the tyre dealers when getting a repair done on the punctured wheel.

2 When puncturing the nearside wheel replace it with the offside wheel and fit the steel wheel on the offside

3 Guard the van while someone else takes the punctured tyre to be repaired

4 Insure with C& CC and use the money saved on insurance to buy an Alloy wheel for the spare

Decisions decisions decisions
 
Mar 28, 2005
831
0
18,880
Visit site
What's the problem with swapping the off side wheel with the nearside wheel when you have reached your destination?

It's only a ten minute job
 
Mar 14, 2005
1,478
434
19,435
Visit site
Hi Bernard

I agree with you this is a weak spot but for us the AL KO locking system has been a a waste of time, it came as standard with our twin axle and the recommendation is that you apply the plate to one wheel and jack up the van to fit the second plate, in my view not a realistic option, so we still use 2 wheelclamps which has the advantage that we can use them on alloy or steel spare wheels.
 
Oct 25, 2006
97
0
0
Visit site
Many thanks to all for the various responses posted. Some interesting and 'different' solutions to this situation.

Following the original posting I have also e-mailed Al-ko seeking their comments and also again to the van manufacturer to see if they are prepared to supply a cost effective alloy as the spare.

Thanks again to all contributors, it is all very helpful in this new venture.
 
Mar 14, 2005
4,638
0
0
Visit site
You made me wonder about getting an alloy spare but I have a Tyron band already on the steel one .

In 30 years I have only had the need to change a wheel once on the road and that was the offside!!

Is my luck about to change.

In the event of a puncture on the door side in a safe place it would mean jacking up offside and putting spare on that side before jacking up the nearside to fit offside alloy.

With the ease of the Aldi trolley jack that would be feasable.
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts