G,
When you say fast drain plug, which are you talking about?
The drain plug is at the bottom left of the cowl, and is accessable without taking the cover off.
The pressure release valve is top left, under the cowl, with the fusible plug a metal "nut" centre top under the cowl.
If you are talking about the pressure release valve, then it should be tight enough to create a seal against its 'O' ring, but not extrememly tight as it is a plastic material and relatively easily broken.
The only way of checking is to take it out and see if any of the threaded part is left inside the heater.
If any is still in, then it is a case of getting it out, and replacing the valve with a new one.