If the response was to me Parksy I wasn't offering an alternative. I was trying to help a fellow caravanner whose hubby likes fishing and a lot of people, myself included, check out sites in whatever area of the country they are in. The site I quoted is only a few miles away from Tarrington as is my home. The difference being is I've stayed at Lucksall and can speak with authority about it but again, although only a few miles from my home I've never visited the Hereford Camping & Caravan Club Site except in the middle of the night whilst attending a 999 call.
In a recent post I tried to help someone regarding Poolsbrook and Skegness Sands, two sites I haven't stayed at but visited whilst at Sherwood Forest Country Park.
If your post was made because of your response in another thread regarding the C&CC you couldn't be more wrong.
There are many times when posts have been made regarding fishing sites and I've responded with both Winchcombe and Ebury Hill, both C&CC sites but neither are in the Hereford area.