The Caravan Club article is IMO an irresponsible piece of tripe. I spoke with them, and IMO they do not have a single shred of credible evidence with which to back their claims.
If you want to know how good or bad these cars are, take a look at www.pocuk.com and see what problems owners are reporting and receiving help for. This is an owners club with (from the member list) several thousand members. As such, it has to be a vastly more significant source of information than the CC Red Pennant Scheme. The posts on POCUK aren't censored, so you will get a clear and honest picture.
WRT overheating - the article claimed a "notable number". I suspect that if you were to ask how many of any car commonly used for towing had overheated, you'd get enough to make a "notable number". IOW, Pajeros are no worse than any other car (and, from noting numbers broken down at the roadside and comparing reports on alt.fan.landrover with those on the Pajero Owners Club, they are more reliable than the Discovery).
WRT clutch failure - the vast majority of Pajeros are autos, which don't have a clutch and flywheel. So, any clutch problems must be confined to those with manual transmission. Now, I very much doubt that there are enough manual Pajeros in his area for that one Welsh "specialist" to see the alleged problem "day-in, day-out". AFAICT, the original claim is from one disgruntled owner, whose importer may have used this false claim to fob off his customer. In any case, except for some 1993 2.8 TDs, manual Pajeros have the same clutch as their Shogun counterparts.
When I spoke with "Suzanne", she told me that her goal was to highlight the lack of dealer support for grey imports, either here or abroad, and that it is likely they won't be able to do a roadside fix for these vehicles. Now, I find
it strange that she (and Barry Williams, the editor of the club magazine and author of that crock of crud) chose to illustrate this by picking on one of the few grey imports that actually has full UK main-dealer support. I also cannot believe that UK-spec car would have any better support in a foreign country than will any other vehicle of a specification not sold in that country. In any case, they did not say there was a support issue with grey imports -- they implied that the Pajero is prone to overheating and clutch failure (neither of which is true) and claimed it to be "unsuitable for towing" (which, given that a greater percentage of Pajeros than most other marques are used for towing, is also untrue).
AFAICT, the Caravan Club have not followed the Press Code of Practice (of which the very first tenet is, "The Press must take care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorted information, including pictures.") Caravan Club members deserve better than this. However, the code also states, "A significant inaccuracy, mis-leading statement or distortion once recognised must be corrected, promptly and with due prominence, and - where appropriate - an apology published." So, I know that I and several others have contacted the Club to point out their errors and I wait with interest for the retraction and apology that the Code of Practice requires.