Possibly a little bit of clarity would not go amiss here.
As you all recall when Messrs Broon and Darling offered the money in October they insisted on being repaid at 12% interest as a priority, which the banks have been doing. Now Broon and Darling have recognised that this was maybe not the smartest move and have now reduced it to a more realistic 5% and changed the Preference shares to Ordinary Shares. Northern Rock has been hellbent on repaying money to HMG to such an extent it has stopped all lending and asked its mortgage holders to go elsehwere. That is a great way to get lending moving again
RBS is about to post the largest corporate loss in UK history and yes, that is a matter of concern. However over 20 billion of the 28 billion loss is from ABN/AMRO and the loans that Bank gave out before it was bought by RBS. Yes, RBS should have done due diligence and I suspect they did, and were assured by auditors that the loan book of ABN/AMRO was all in accordance with accounting practice AT THAT TIME. Now it is not. Exclude that and the loss is a mere 7 billion, small potatoes in the current climate and compared with what the Bank assets were worth just a few months ago. In addition they also made a 600 million profit on all their UK operations. So is this a busted flush Company?
I would also point out that not all shareholders are large Corporations or fat cats. I am a small one myself and yes, my wife and I have lost a lot of money. Many older poeple here in Scotland had their savings invested in both RBS and the old BOS ( before it lost its way and joined Halifax) as they trusted these institutions. After all these were 2 of the oldest Banks in the UK. Also many of the shareholders are employees who purchased their shares through stock option plans and these were often the 'bonuses' they received. Now they are worthless. So do not be so critical of people who have worked hard and supported their employers the best way they could. The combined workforce of Lloyds/HBOS for example is 140000 people. They are certainly not all at the top. Throw them all on the street and then think what will happen to all of us. Also do remember that all Pension Funds have invested in these same Banks, and many pensioners will now feel the result in a reduced pension in their old age. The share price is much more than a tool for fat cats to win.
Yes, the management have made some foolhardy decisions, but again if these decisions were based on information received that was valid at the time, then hindsight is a wonderful excuse. Broon should know considering the wolefully bad decisions he has made over the last 10 years that he has virtually bankrupted the country even before this mess came about. He made the situation even worse by changing all the regulatory bodies and encouraging a 'spend spend' Policy to make himself look good.
So please consider things more openly. Yes, I would like to see certain individuals face a Court of Law, but what would you charge them with? Malpractice? If they then produced evidence to show they followed the rules of the Government, and respected auditors, and the legal advice provided, then what? If they did not, then throw the 'book' at them but it is noticeable that there has been no movement in that direction from HMG. I wonder why?