Anyone got a deisel Saab as a tow car?

Sep 6, 2015
61
0
0
I think I need to change my car - it's a Renault Megane tourer with 106bhp diesel engine. Its a very nice car and it does ok with our Luna Zenith (1100 mtplm) but struggles a bit with hills and children and fully loaded kit.

A friend of mine has a very nice petrol saab 93 - but its thirsty. I can't afford a newer car but I could change my Renault for a similar age / miles Saab. Read mixed reports about the diesel engines but I understand they make a good tow car.
 
Aug 23, 2009
3,167
4
20,685
From my dodgy memory bank I think the problems were around cam belts and water pumps. I know the petrols go on and on forever. I once looked at the 9-5 estate but it was too light for the van we had at the time. I should think fine for your 1100kg though. Always liked them though and had it of been heavier I would possibly have gone for the 3.0T?
 
Mar 14, 2005
18,674
3,931
50,935
I have personally had 5 SAAB's and had the pleasure of driving 4 others at different times. In all cases I have really appreciated the comfort of the seating (In my opinion the best standard car seats I have ever found). Solidly and heavily built they seem to use a thicker gauge of metal compared to the rest of the mass market offerings from Ford, Fiat PSA,GM, and heh Japanese pretenders.

Performance wise they were usually in teh top three of their respective classes and years, though BMW's & Mercs were usually rated a little better.

I have towed trailers and caravans with 4 different models and all have been more than adequate for the task. 1973 Saab 99 Combi Coupe, 1986 9000i, 1989 9000SE, 2001 9-3 2.2Diesel SE.

My last SAAB, was the 2001 model 93. 2.2 diesel Turbo. And whilst I did not use this for a caravan I did tow a large TA box trailer with it loaded to about 1200kg. Plenty of low down torque and despite being front wheeled drive it managed very well in putting the power down. Having said that it was only 115BHP. But despite it giving away several BHP to its competition it always managed surprisingly well.

II only got rid of it in 2013, becasue of other problems, It used a GM derived chassis and diesel engine used in the Vectra's, and Signums and it suffered two common problems with theGM cars. Firstly the steering box detached from the front bulhhead, and the engine suffered what appeared to be fuel starvation after it had stood overnight and it was difficult to start. Once running it was fine. The Same engine was used in the 9-5 model, and I saw similar reports.

Later models used a Fiat derived 1.9L engine with 150BHP which seemed to be overall more reliable.

I have liked Saab's, and I would have gone for another if the company had not been driven into the ground by GM who forced them to ditch many of the 'quirks' which made a Saab a Saab. And also when I needed to change the company had just be closed for good. Personally I think the motoring world is a poorer place for not having a manufacture that dared to be different.

Whatever Saab you look at it will be second hand. It will probably need some unique spares which are becoming increasingly scarce. A full service history is a must, and whilst many Saabs notch up impressive mileages, look for the lowest possible. Those that use the Vectra chassis, make sure the steering box mount has been moded

My dilemma was I needed a reliable car, Saabs were now out of the picture so it was a case of looking for something else that came close. I tried a Ford - big mistake. I considered a Volvo's Another make with a good Swedish history, but recently they had been under Ford's wing and they had suffered in some ways like Saab under GM. I ended up with VW Passat - Oh for a Saab!
 
Feb 4, 2017
10
0
0
Having had two Renaults a 2006 Megane, and a 2010 Scenic both with 1.5 DCi 106 diesels
I personally would have your engine ECU remapped, that would give you approx 25% extra
(27 BHP) to play with at a cost of approx £280

** But then I would advise informing your insurance company**

That way you dont have to fork out for another unknown car ??
 
Sep 6, 2015
61
0
0
Yes that is an option - but also the kids keep growing and Mrs TM looks wistfully and longingly at adverts for biggers 'vans - so I'm now looking at Volvo V70s. I'll have to get a pipe and a cardigan to go with it. THanks for all the comments anyway.
 
Nov 16, 2015
11,771
3,970
40,935
Tentmonster, we had a 3 litre diesel, Vectra, lovely car to tow with, but started to play up and looked at Volvo XC70's, loved the car then the wife drove it and found the head rests were NOT adjustable, and as she drives with the seat verticale, the car was of no use to us.
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts