hi all.
having been with BT, Tiscali, (now talk talk) Virgin, and now Sky, I would say that all the providers have pluses and minuses it depends on what you are looking for cheap is not always the best, or in the long run the cheapest.
BT, was fine in the early days! as they had the corner on the market but speeds were slow and the service was intremittent the big draw back was the line rental for the phone, I have no idea what the new infinity is like but it did seem expensive for what was a basic package the last time I looked.
Tiscali. was billiant when it first came out, broadband and phone for £10 a month inclusive the phone line included all UK no's including 0845 and 0847 and international calls to certain desinations were also free, in the 3 years we were with them we never paid one penny in call charges, this changed when Talk Talk took over they changed the package and also the way we were billed. the price escalated and the service went downhill warning here "Talk Talk do not like losing customers and will make it as difficult as possible for you to change later. they refused to give us the MAC codes for the line effectively cutting us off without paying BT to re establish the line. and blocked all internet access, e-mail accounts and phone on the day I cancelled but still wanted one month extra payment they never got it however and maybe the reason we didn't get the Mac codes. so be warned??.
Virgin were a waste of space from day one never got the fulll service I ordered TV was mediocre an old PACE box instead of the plus box ordered and call charges for everything exept for calling Virgin to complain. service was slow despite the optical fibre and the broadband was throttled down at busy times and the more you used it, we only went with them because it was the only supplier that would not charge us for connecting the now defunct phone line final straw was when they offered new customers a better package all inclusive inc HD for 1/2 the price we were paying.
we are now with Sky upto press everything has been fine it's not the chapest at £38 a month but the extras inc full HD, sky go, on demand, and free phone and broadband seem ok. the broadband service (while not the fastest) has been faultless and does not get cut off when the phone is used "unlike BT and Talk Talk" we did look at all the alternatives like Primus and Plus net befroe singing with Sky but most seem to be around the £25 mark a month after installation plus call charges.
no one seems to do the old broadband only bit for a few quid a month "exept for a dongle" all have the extras that you pay for on top so I suppose it is a case of what you can get extra for the money, one thing is for sure I would not have Talk Talk if they were the ONLY supplier available, but that is just my opinion.
before I go just make sure Joe that if you decide to get Talk Talk that you insist they give you the wide band service "not the narrow one" when it is transfered from BT or whoever and dont use their server for e-mails, as this will be deleted if you cancell later on, and if possible get the MAC codes,
colin