Hi Dustydog,
Never happen mate. Free gifts to existing subscribers doesn't make financial sense, less profits.
As you say, Haymarket aren't a charity, they are out to make money. I think you may be overplaying your importance to them, I'm afraid. It would be different if a huge group of us subscribers decided to defect, if we don't get a loyalty bonus, but I can't see that happening.
Fair do's if there was a PC loyalty scheme, like in a local / social club, the Co-op etc,when I subscribed. But I knew that this is a magazine and a business and I wouldn't expect to get anything other than what I pay for.
I agree that loyalty is an excellent attribute and should / could be rewarded in some circumstances eg, the Co-op with their dividend.
I don't think that we are very far apart in our opinions Dustydog.
Cheers,
Alex.