• Thanks to each and every one of you for being part of the Practical Caravan community! We hope you have a fantastic Christmas and a joyous holiday season!

Smoke / co2 alarms

Nov 3, 2025
30
4
35
After much research I have been advised that your smoke / co2 alarms have to meet certain regulations, EN 50291-2, EN 14604.after having two fail in the caravan, anyone recommend alarms that actually last and don’t quit and 6 months ?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3811.jpeg
    IMG_3811.jpeg
    179.3 KB · Views: 2
Nov 11, 2009
25,591
9,372
50,935
After much research I have been advised that your smoke / co2 alarms have to meet certain regulations, EN 50291-2, EN 14604.after having two fail in the caravan, anyone recommend alarms that actually last and don’t quit and 6 months ?
I’ve always used Fire Angel or Kidde smoke or CO alarms in the caravan and house. Not had any unreasonable failures. What make(s) did you use?
 
  • Like
Reactions: toad a caravan
Nov 16, 2015
12,538
4,686
40,935
I replaced a Fire angel 50291-2 which lasted about 6 years, with another FA. But with a replaceable battery. First one had a non replaceable battery, and non rechargeable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: toad a caravan

JTQ

May 7, 2005
4,127
1,860
20,935
I am having more success with the current Kidde CO unit with a "for life battery" than I had with either their and Fire Angel's units with replaceable batteries. This has a "replace unit after 10 years from installation" label and I installed it on 27/02/2018. [just been and checked label pre posting]
The vans smoke alarms like your have exhibited short lives, but I basically accept replacing these low cost items. These have all used a 9 volt alkaline battery.
I have not used, nor would I the dual function units.
 
Last edited:
Nov 3, 2025
30
4
35
I am having more success with the current Kidde CO unit with a "for life battery" than I had with either their and Fire Angel's units with replaceable batteries. This has a "replace unit after 10 years from installation" label and I installed it on 27/02/2018. [just been and checked label pre posting]
The vans smoke alarms like your have exhibited short lives, but I basically accept replacing these low cost items. These have all used a 9 volt alkaline battery.
I have not used, nor would I the dual function units.
Thinking of going that way myself, getting a co2 stand alone unit and a smoke alarm on its own, only thing about the fire angel smoke alarm from reading reviews is that it has a flashing light on it , which wouldn’t be good in a caravan, would be like lighting every time it cycles through it’s course lol
 
Nov 3, 2025
30
4
35
So do Screwfix and Safelincs too, but that doesn’t answer the OP’s question of who can recommend an alarm(s).
Safelincs are a joke , was them I had a warranty problem with, they said because I used a non regulated unit in a caravan, my warranty was null and void, was them that quoted regulations to me , you can’t use house smoke detectors in a caravan because of the vibration!
 

TRENDING THREADS

Latest posts