Just heard of manuals (09) jumping out of gear for no reasonWhilst I personally don't like them and wouldn't buy one the only complaint I've heard of (and many friends have them) is that they can get noisy as they get older. If you stick to pre 2006 the tax won't make a difference between manual and Auto but then onwards manual will be cheaper to tax than Auto. Know people with manual and tiptronic and not heard any particular complaints about either so if costs not an issue whichever you prefer driving. For me it would be auto every time.