Having read through this thread for the first time today, and being a member of the Caravan Club, I have to agree with a few points here.
I personally dont remember being asked for my opinion on deposits etc, but there is a possibility that I deleted the email before I read it. I dont understand why people are so against deposits, if they have honourable intentions of using the pitch they have booked, surely a deposit equal to 1 nights pitch fees isnt unreasonable.
I cant knock the quality of the sites I've used, which if Im honest isnt too many. Up until recently I've avoided CL sites, as I like a place with a bit of activity, however having recently stopped at a CL, I must say Im warming to them. However, when it comes to the CC owned sites, I dont find them competitive on price to be honest.
We Caravan all year round and (not including CL sites) Ive not managed to find a CC site that is actually cheaper than a privately owned site of a comparable standard in the same area, and in some cases they are more expensive than some privately owned sites with better facilities.
This begs the question of why am I paying £30 odd pounds per year membership, to pay MORE for a pitch????
The only advantage for me personally is the Mayday Breakdown Cover. If it werent for the fact that I think CC are the only place that offer this level of cover, I would have no reason to be a member.
We are relatively new to caravanning (in our 3rd year), and are trying to explore the UK as best we can, so we try to pick an area to explore, as opposed to wanting to stop at any particular site, and so far 9 out of 10 times, we havent booked a CC site, either because:
a: there isnt a site in the area we want to visit
b: there is a site but its booked up every weekend so we cant get a full weeks pitch
c: the site is not competitive on price compared to other sites.
If anyone could direct me to another source of breakdown cover that will offer the same level as Mayday, I wouldnt rejoin again.
None of the 'members offers' are of use to me (except breakdown), and I can subscribe to far better magazines than the one that occassionally drops through my letterbox
Rick