Fenwicks Top &Tail v Elsan organic

[RayS]

Anyone tried both ? if so which one preferred ?

 

[SirRogerFFS]

Hello Ray S. We did use Fenwicks top and tail once in our caravan but her indoors didnt like the smell. If I remember correctly it has a pine fragrance and course she doesnt like the smell of pine .Sadly cant help you with Elsan but I must say the Top and Tail worked well .As you will see on other post on toilet flush I use the one available from Aldi I was using it long before Aldi started to stock it sadly paid more but I do now stock up from Aldi.
Sir Roger

 

[Mel]

Hi. Not used Fenwicks but do use Elsan Organic. We have tried a variety of green treatments including thetfords, One Chem and kem direct and Dometic tabs. Much prefer the Elsan, much nicer smell and seemed to break matter down the best. Didn't like the One Chem smell at all: rather fishy to my nose
Mel