Allan,the three points you,ve just made are very fair,i agree with all of them.and safty is at the top of the tree.with out talking we,d get nowhere,and its good to hear other peoples points.
Brian, I think the article was in Caravan magazine. Unfortunatly I don't tend to keep back copies for much more than six months these days.And of course it would seem the only real life test to be carried out showed that a car with abs towing a caravan stopped quicker than a car with abs solo.
I have mags going back many years and when I have time I will see if I can find the artical although I have had a clear out on a couple of occations so it may not be there. From memory I would say it wasn't either of the clubs and I'm sure it wasn't PCM, so that leaves either Caravan or Caravan Life.
Brian (",)
You may be right that the conditions were ideal but until we know what the actual conditions were, we won't know how realistic or typical they are.That being the case then Lutz.
You then have to agree that a lot more force from the vans weight transfers to the car at times.
As so many other factors from tyre grip/type/pressure to road surface type and conditions and more effect braking I believe Shorter / Quicker braking with caravan in tow and ABS equipped car may only occur under very ideal sittuations.
Without knowing all details, I concede that the information may not apply under all circumstances (such as on wet roads, if the tyres on the caravan have less grip than those of the car, etc., etc.)Lutz. Allthough you are right in one way about the downforce.
If caravanbbraking is degraded the downward force will not only change to forward force but also lift as well as the cars nose dips without full braking lift will be generated to the rear of the car!
There are dozens of scientific based reports re caravan braking yet no where around the world can I find one thing relating to shorter braking distance.
I don't doubt the report, but it just can not be a blanket indication that you will stop in shorter towing a caravn with a ABS tow car.
A good driver can out brake ABS if he is good at Cadence braking after all. But you have to be GOOD and well skilled.