Interesting thread.
My considerations with a used EV would include, will it tow my caravan without causing ‘range anxiety’ & just like buying a used petrol or diesel, where I would have to consider other costs such as cam belt change etc, how much is a new battery going to cost if necessary?
I don’t like to dawdle & like to get from A to B in one hit. Even if I need to fill up fuel pumps are stop & go!
Battery replacement costs are astronomical.
I live in the ‘now’ so not really interested in
“the prices will come down” argument.
EV’s have their place in the city environment for instance, but for towing distances (I towed my van to Perpignan last year) I can’t be convinced to extend my travel time with multiple stops en route!
The word ‘eventually’ seems to do a lot of heavy lifting when discussing the merits (or otherwise) of EV’s.
I'm not sure why you have included battery replacement amongst normal day to day running costs. Despite all the dire warnings as EV's began to take off, the batteries (with a few exceptions) are lasting far longer than the naysayers would like.
Its difficult to make a true like for like comparison as its not apples to apples, but in terms of the probability of needing a battery replacement in an EV, is more akin to the need to have an engine replacement in an ICE vehicle. In practice a failing battery is actually a lower probability than an IC engine may need replacing.
Batteries do decline in their capability but generally the rate of degradation is far slower than predicted, and that is why some manufacturers are able to offer a 100,000 mile guarantee of at least 80% capacity. ICE engines also deteriorate they progressively reduce the maximum power as their mileage increases and wear, and during that period they need servicing materials and a strong possibility of new parts such as timing belts and other consumables.
Despite the above, you may still feel an EV is not right for you.