I totally agree with the idea that forming an opinion based on the unqualified opinion of fellow forum members does seem odd.
A VPN only encrypts your traffic to the other end of the VPN. Then it’s open to the internet.
The only value of a VPN is to change either your IP address as it appears in the internet, or to change the apparent geographical location of your internet presence. Any other value comes from the additional capabilities surrounding the VPN (add blocker, additional firewall, inline IDS, IPS).
My credentials for the above comment is 30 years in the computer networking industry, the last 26 of which have been as a senior systems architect for the largest networking vendor on the planet.