Hi Static
Yes I agree totally. I cannot tell you how frustrating it is when an uncontrolled dog or child or adult blunders up to us when we are trying to establish that trust that has been lost.
I do understand Brians point, but whoever takes on the dog that he gave back will, like you and I, have to work hard at rebuilding the trust.
And yes, the dog whose owner died and which had such a bad reaction to being put in kennels with many other dogs arround it, is a collie cross. Our first dog was a Lab/Border Collie X and the one we have now ia a GSD/Rough Collie X.
He is still a bit of a s*d with other dogs (M&F) but we are getting there.
I would be interested in any training tips you have. The only "device" I have used was an air horn but I used it once with disasterous results. Out on a Forest walk, a lady came towards us with a well behaved Spaniel on a lead. My dog started acting up and so, as instructed by the NCDL(as was) guy, I got out the air horn and gave a blast.
As they say in some books - lots of things happened at once. The best was that my dog just sat down and did nothing. Not so good was about three pheasants in the brush right next to this lady suddenly took flight with loud squawks and flapping of wings.
The Spaniel ran round in a circle and nearly pulled its owner off balance. This lady also looked as though she was about to have a heart attack.
When things had calmed down and she had untangled herself I said I was sorry. She just walked past me and muttered "Bloody Fool".
I havn't used it again.